So I am not ready to officially make this list yet, but while doing my research I realized how bad this decade sucks for music. Well it didn’t really suck, but it was mired in mediocrity. The bands that will make up my top 10 aren’t even in the same class or league as the top 10 albums of the 90’s. To be perfectly honest the top 20-30 albums of the 90’s are maybe equal to the top 10 of the naughts.
Who was our Nirvana Nevermind? Who was our R.E.M. Out of Time or Automatic for the People? Who was our Oasis Definitely Maybe or Whats the Story Morning Glory? Who was our U2? Who was our Foo Fighters? One of the best Pedro the Lion albums came out in 98′. The best Foo Fighters was from the 90’s. My favorite Juliana Theory album came out in 1999. Radiohead killed it in the 90’s with The Bends and OK Computer, two of the best albums of all time in my opinion. And still think about the albums from Green Day, Bush, Alanis Morissette, Hole, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden…I could go on and on. Most of these were just the first that came to my head when thinking about good music from the 90’s.
Maybe time will change my opinion of the 2000’s. There have been a ton of albums I really love come out, but when I compare them to the past they just don’t hold their weight. My goal with my top 10 list of the 2000’s will be albums that stood the test of time and will still sound good to me in 10 years. That cuts out a lot of albums that I loved from 2002-2006…emo will never…nevermind. Oh yeah and I forgot to list Pinkerton and the Blue Album. Shame on me.
let’s hope veckatimest & kid a are in there.
it’s because you’re old(er than me). when I’m writing a music blog about the top albums of the 10’s compared to the 00’s i’ll say the same thing. it’s relative.
but pinkerton better be on there.
It’s hard to explain Nate, you’re a little right and a little wrong about the age thing. I’ll explain when I do the top 10. I did think about that though.
And Tyler I’ll post you’re top 10 and my top 10. I can promise you will hate my top 10
I’d agree and disagree with you on your statement about 2000’s music being underwhelming. Certainly, the 90’s were way better popular rock music, but the indie musicians of this decade have not ceased to amaze me. First off, while OK Computer may have been a complete masterpiece, Kid A is still an utterly fantastic album, and in my opinion, Radiohead’s best. Sigur Ros’s Takk has been one of my most listened to albums of the last two years, and I love it more every time I listen to it. Arcade Fire’s Funeral is another great cd. It’s also good to remember that we’re all products of the decade we grew up in. The 90’s will probably always stand out to you as one of the best decades for music. For rock, I would agree, but the 2000’s have been awesome for the lesser known bands. Of course, if we’re talking pop, this might have been the worst decade ever.
Yeah! Gimme more controversy!
You should say something about how your list is more objective than subjective and make sure everyone knows that disagreeing with you means they’ve been blinded by their personal bias.
Just a suggestion.
I am always right Collin. I can’t believe anyone would even remotely think to disagree with my perfect music taste.
Willy is right about the indie artists. The death of the record labels really opened up the doors for more artist like that to find a fan base.
You can’t really compare Pearl Jam and Sigur Ros or Arcade Fire and Oasis.
Only time will tell how to compare these bands.
deja entendeu by brand new, for sure
When I was in college, I remember wondering when or if I would begin to cave to the bias of coming-of-age music nostalgia. Of course, at the time I was delusional enough to believe I might never become the old dude who hated “the youngin’s music”.
I think I have to admit that some time in the last few years I took my seat in the rocking chair that I’ll be condemning new music from until I’m dead. But I will say this in an attempt at “objective” historical analysis:
The music that has changed my life more than any other, I actually discovered in the 2000s. Why? Well, when I look back to the 90s, like you guys have said, all of my favorite music came from rock-oriented major record labels. (Weezer, Radiohead, Ben Folds Five, Third Eye Blind, Sublime)
In the 2000s, in my opinion, the landscape of major-label rock has been a testosterone-fueled wasteland (with some exceptions, i.e. Jack White) — as if a homophobic, walking, talking man-penis was writing every song on the radio only for profit. Maybe a better metaphor would be a rock Titanic, fueled by huge, money-burning engine rooms and captained by a uniform-clad set of cock-and-balls. One thing seems for sure, the ship is sinking.
In the 90’s, turning on the radio sufficed for me — there were lots of great artists to be found and I was satisfied leaving it at that. Now things are different; now we have the internet for music finding. Whether the chicken or the egg came first, I don’t know, but all the creative people seem to have decided to jump the major label money ship and become net pioneers. The amazing thing is that it seems to be working!
A number of amazing rock artists have found a home in the internet-aided world of indie and quasi-major labels, (Coheed and Cambria …etc.) while another growing throng of musicians are putting out some of the most inventive music I’ve ever heard that blur the rock/pop boundaries with genres that never sold well on the money ship. (St. Vincent, Amanda Palmer, Arcade Fire, Dirty Projectors, Grizzly Bear)
Perhaps best of all, the lack of easy-to-find, quality radio music has also resulted in my finding listening time for discovering amazing radio-neglected genres and artists for the first time. (Ralph Stanley, Tim Eriksen, the Sacred Harp hymn tradition)
In my opinion, the 90s OWN the 00s in regards to “official/sponsored/professional” music. I think the issue that will make it difficult for us to wrap our heads around the 00s will be the shifting paradigm that asks the question: “what is the definition of official/sponsored/professional music?”
In my opinion, the emperor has been thrown down, to the benefit of “peasant” musicians everywhere.
Daniel you really need to post that on your blog, good stuff.
Yeah I was thinking about featuring that reply in my main top 10 of the Decade. Stephen do you have yours ready?
“as if a homophobic, walking, talking man-penis was writing every song on the radio only for profit.” – Daniel Machado
This could be the greatest (and most accurate) description of modern rock radio I’ve ever heard.